{ "axis_disagreement_prints": 5, "episodes": { "2018 MLCC": [ "2017-12-31", "2018-03-31", "2018-06-30", "2018-09-30", "2018-12-31" ], "2021 ABF": [ "2020-09-30", "2020-12-31", "2021-03-31", "2021-06-30", "2021-09-30" ], "2023 HBM": [ "2022-12-31", "2023-03-31", "2023-06-30", "2023-09-30", "2023-12-31" ] }, "evidence_manifest_path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/evidence.json", "evidence_manifest_sha256": "6cef4b9dd74cc03627df466cd14f32c321f5f78410871727d553433059b71779", "evidence_status": "preliminary_proxy", "input_correlations": { "adoption_breadth": 0.8265, "capital_commitment": 0.9056, "chokepoint_tension": 0.8542, "committed_pipeline": 0.963, "relief_window_tension": 0.9302, "supply_cycle_gate": 0.9077, "unit_cost_deflation": 0.3912, "usage_growth": 0.916 }, "input_pack_path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/inputs.json", "kill_check_passed": false, "loudest_input": "committed_pipeline", "max_abs_input_correlation": 0.963, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "pack_id": "preliminary-proxy-v1", "pack_sha256": "c3b1427d4845a69a399315674961739549532eb381bee0be3a17bbfc5b9bde69", "print_objects": [ { "as_of": "2017-12-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2017-12-31.json", "sha256": "e715f20bdd0854f4c97eeb4410eae8593410f605f398a23357633d3a1699fdd3" }, { "as_of": "2018-03-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2018-03-31.json", "sha256": "ffbd711439019cd0efd7088ae8ea0ea1314c97f5b7bdada331bde402d992feab" }, { "as_of": "2018-06-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2018-06-30.json", "sha256": "d14e5f49bfe19655811909a35e534db7cb89d444e8aedff1bfdefb82c874f3b0" }, { "as_of": "2018-09-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2018-09-30.json", "sha256": "602bbd2172b504e0cc4601eb05e9e27fa25de85055fff5dbaf9a7833af5f4d28" }, { "as_of": "2018-12-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2018-12-31.json", "sha256": "638ccf7d06d1363d859bb84ef3eb2ba2fc2d5d4efaeebd01925e988b37bbf0f9" }, { "as_of": "2020-09-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2020-09-30.json", "sha256": "1418686da2b7ef1c7f214388a8ab1ce3be6f841680d0799574b9c9a7ecc807c6" }, { "as_of": "2020-12-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2020-12-31.json", "sha256": "1aedc390a36feaf71ed59ff27e41f037bdded7829274f2294f9cfb70e210b96a" }, { "as_of": "2021-03-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2021-03-31.json", "sha256": "bc96f036420971ccc875d218f052e10167439d77fb7db2e402cc37602e184127" }, { "as_of": "2021-06-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2021-06-30.json", "sha256": "0644a4b9ebfe531805795ef7b1dc67db9439adfdbbf0425320d87bbdef4643cd" }, { "as_of": "2021-09-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2021-09-30.json", "sha256": "cd278121f17646347ccead9211ed06bb7a842a5190143c3267b5f7b1c51f9d34" }, { "as_of": "2022-12-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2022-12-31.json", "sha256": "8cccdb288fa50ca74d396f02d3bac0aa30405b47d6ac5bf43069ff07ef0e9de0" }, { "as_of": "2023-03-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2023-03-31.json", "sha256": "ba8ad1f7f6f4443402d2fa7053f1f421c8912d60be35ca269021d89817d4371c" }, { "as_of": "2023-06-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2023-06-30.json", "sha256": "db32c8ce0882abfb371647c8c911a8241a1c3949c4e1d0d7e281180a8b249593" }, { "as_of": "2023-09-30", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2023-09-30.json", "sha256": "8c459114d1d0fdeeb0be5b2c658e94365a2d830faece6b56cc45b0214ed7bfce" }, { "as_of": "2023-12-31", "path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/prints/2023-12-31.json", "sha256": "aca458ef3d602d61468a6803ea79d6222fed6514679f12f4eeba6c07eaa53fb0" } ], "publication_blockers": [ "evidence_manifest_not_validated", "evidence_check_failed:point_in_time_verified", "evidence_check_failed:independent_sources_verified", "input_correlation_above_0_95" ], "publication_eligible": false, "schema_version": "1.0.0", "manifest_path": "replays/preliminary-proxy-v1/manifest.json", "manifest_sha256": "3cced9b4cbafac49b6de813405a8a03eb519ff78f91d2e96f0306e7d47ffc0b8", "prints": [ { "agreement_score": 78.65, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.18, "score": 59, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.08, "score": 58, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.04, "score": 54, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.28, "score": 68, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 8.5, "score": 56.666666666666664, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 59.13, "state": "neutral" }, "diffusion_index": 48.45, "dispersion_band": [ 37.78, 59.13 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2017-12-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2017-12-31", "rationale": "Demand is neutral at 59.1/100 (100% coverage); supply is loose at 37.8/100 (100%). The 21.4-point axis spread implies 78.7/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "BALANCED", "raw_value": null, "score": 50, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.44, "score": 40, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2017-12-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.34, "score": 23.333333333333336, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 37.78, "state": "loose" }, "verdict": "SUPPLY_AHEAD" }, { "agreement_score": 87.93, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.31, "score": 65.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.2, "score": 70, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.02, "score": 52, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.35, "score": 75, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 10.5, "score": 70, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 66.5, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 72.53, "dispersion_band": [ 66.5, 78.57 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2018-03-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2018-03-31", "rationale": "Demand is high at 66.5/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 78.6/100 (100%). The 12.1-point axis spread implies 87.9/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.68, "score": 75.71428571428572, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-03-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.66, "score": 70, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 78.57, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 71.47, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.37, "score": 68.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.27, "score": 77, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.04, "score": 30.000000000000004, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.41, "score": 81, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 12, "score": 80, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 67.3, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 81.56, "dispersion_band": [ 67.3, 95.83 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2018-06-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2018-06-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 67.3/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 95.8/100 (100%). The 28.5-point axis spread implies 71.5/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.91, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-06-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.88, "score": 97.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 95.83, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 50.13, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.02, "score": 45.00000000000001, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.06, "score": 35, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.08, "score": 10.000000000000002, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.24, "score": 64, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 7, "score": 46.666666666666664, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 40.13, "state": "neutral" }, "diffusion_index": 65.06, "dispersion_band": [ 40.13, 90 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2018-09-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2018-09-30", "rationale": "Demand is neutral at 40.1/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 90.0/100 (100%). The 49.9-point axis spread implies 50.1/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.88, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-09-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.74, "score": 80, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 90, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "SUPPLY_CONSTRAINED" }, { "agreement_score": 97.33, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.16, "score": 10.000000000000002, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.14, "score": 15, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.18, "score": 68, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.03, "score": 32.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 3, "score": 20, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 29.1, "state": "low" }, "diffusion_index": 27.77, "dispersion_band": [ 26.43, 29.1 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2018-12-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2018-12-31", "rationale": "Demand is low at 29.1/100 (100% coverage); supply is loose at 26.4/100 (100%). The 2.7-point axis spread implies 97.3/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "BREAKING", "raw_value": null, "score": 10, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.53, "score": 54.28571428571429, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2018-12-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2018 MLCC retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.29, "score": 14.999999999999995, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#135-de-rated-choke-re-entry-gate-frozen-2026-07-06-before-any-code-or-position", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 26.43, "state": "loose" }, "verdict": "SUPPLY_GLUT" }, { "agreement_score": 68.18, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.66, "score": 83, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.42, "score": 92, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.24, "score": 74, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.49, "score": 89, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 11.5, "score": 76.66666666666667, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 82.93, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 67.02, "dispersion_band": [ 51.11, 82.93 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2020-09-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2020-09-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 82.9/100 (100% coverage); supply is balanced at 51.1/100 (100%). The 31.8-point axis spread implies 68.2/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "BALANCED", "raw_value": null, "score": 50, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.57, "score": 59.99999999999999, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-09-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.46, "score": 43.333333333333336, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 51.11, "state": "balanced" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_EXPANSION" }, { "agreement_score": 90.83, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.81, "score": 90.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.46, "score": 96, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.31, "score": 81, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.57, "score": 97, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 13.5, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 90.9, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 86.31, "dispersion_band": [ 81.73, 90.9 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2020-12-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2020-12-31", "rationale": "Demand is high at 90.9/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 81.7/100 (100%). The 9.2-point axis spread implies 90.8/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.72, "score": 81.42857142857143, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2020-12-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.69, "score": 73.74999999999999, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 81.73, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 99.73, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.92, "score": 96, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.48, "score": 98, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.38, "score": 88, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.63, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 15.5, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 96.4, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 96.53, "dispersion_band": [ 96.4, 96.67 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2021-03-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2021-03-31", "rationale": "Demand is high at 96.4/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 96.7/100 (100%). The 0.3-point axis spread implies 99.7/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.94, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-03-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.93, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 96.67, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 89.27, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.54, "score": 77, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.31, "score": 81, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.29, "score": 79, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.51, "score": 91, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 14, "score": 93.33333333333334, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 84.27, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 89.63, "dispersion_band": [ 84.27, 95 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2021-06-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2021-06-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 84.3/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 95.0/100 (100%). The 10.7-point axis spread implies 89.3/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.9, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-06-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.86, "score": 95, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 95, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 86.8, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.21, "score": 60.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.12, "score": 62, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.14, "score": 64, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.34, "score": 74, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 10, "score": 66.66666666666667, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 65.43, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 72.03, "dispersion_band": [ 65.43, 78.63 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2021-09-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2021-09-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 65.4/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 78.6/100 (100%). The 13.2-point axis spread implies 86.8/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "EARLY-CRACK", "raw_value": null, "score": 55, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.83, "score": 97.14285714285714, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2021-09-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2021 ABF retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.77, "score": 83.75, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate05-rentry.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 78.63, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 79.93, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.09, "score": 27.500000000000004, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.03, "score": 53, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.16, "score": 66, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.02, "score": 30.000000000000004, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 4, "score": 26.666666666666668, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 40.63, "state": "neutral" }, "diffusion_index": 30.59, "dispersion_band": [ 20.56, 40.63 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2022-12-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2022-12-31", "rationale": "Demand is neutral at 40.6/100 (100% coverage); supply is loose at 20.6/100 (100%). The 20.1-point axis spread implies 79.9/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "BREAKING", "raw_value": null, "score": 10, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.38, "score": 30, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2022-12-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.33, "score": 21.666666666666668, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 20.56, "state": "loose" }, "verdict": "SUPPLY_AHEAD" }, { "agreement_score": 83.52, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.33, "score": 66.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.19, "score": 69, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.28, "score": 78, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.29, "score": 69, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 8.5, "score": 56.666666666666664, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 67.83, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 59.59, "dispersion_band": [ 51.35, 67.83 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2023-03-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2023-03-31", "rationale": "Demand is high at 67.8/100 (100% coverage); supply is balanced at 51.4/100 (100%). The 16.5-point axis spread implies 83.5/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "BALANCED", "raw_value": null, "score": 50, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.54, "score": 55.71428571428572, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-03-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.49, "score": 48.33333333333333, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "books/_frontier/chokepoint_screen/docs/2026-07-06-gate0.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 51.35, "state": "balanced" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_EXPANSION" }, { "agreement_score": 98.89, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.97, "score": 98.5, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.44, "score": 94, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.46, "score": 96, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.55, "score": 95, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 13, "score": 86.66666666666666, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 94.03, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 93.47, "dispersion_band": [ 92.92, 94.03 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2023-06-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2023-06-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 94.0/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 92.9/100 (100%). The 1.1-point axis spread implies 98.9/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.86, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-06-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.81, "score": 88.75, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/research-directions.md#132-gate-0--historical-episode-retrieval-test-frozen-2026-07-06", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 92.92, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 95.66, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 1.18, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.36, "score": 86, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.43, "score": 93, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.46, "score": 86, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 14.5, "score": 96.66666666666666, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 92.33, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 94.5, "dispersion_band": [ 92.33, 96.67 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2023-09-30T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2023-09-30", "rationale": "Demand is high at 92.3/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 96.7/100 (100%). The 4.3-point axis spread implies 95.7/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.96, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-09-30", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.9, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 96.67, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" }, { "agreement_score": 97.53, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "demand": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "usage_growth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Inference usage / spend growth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.88, "score": 94, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "adoption_breadth", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Open-model adoption breadth", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.49, "score": 99, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "unit_cost_deflation", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Provider unit-cost deflation", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": -0.49, "score": 99, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "capital_commitment", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Hyperscaler capital commitment", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.39, "score": 79, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "committed_pipeline", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Committed data-center pipeline", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 15.2, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.2 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Demand intensity", "score": 94.2, "state": "high" }, "diffusion_index": 95.44, "dispersion_band": [ 94.2, 96.67 ], "fixture": false, "freshness": { "excluded": [], "oldest_included_days": null, "report": "retrospective proxy reconstruction; not point-in-time publication eligible" }, "generated_at": "2023-12-31T00:00:00", "jevons_scenarios": { "jevons_intact": { "binding_until": 2041, "overbuild_year": null, "peak_desired_gw": 6177, "peak_desired_year": 2031, "regime_flip_year": 2032 }, "monetization_break": { "binding_until": null, "overbuild_year": 2029, "peak_desired_gw": 72.5, "peak_desired_year": 2028, "regime_flip_year": 2028 }, "saturating": { "binding_until": 2032, "overbuild_year": 2033, "peak_desired_gw": 463.9, "peak_desired_year": 2030, "regime_flip_year": 2031 } }, "methodology_version": "2026-07-10.v1", "print_id": "2023-12-31", "rationale": "Demand is high at 94.2/100 (100% coverage); supply is tight at 96.7/100 (100%). The 2.5-point axis spread implies 97.5/100 agreement.", "schema_version": "1.0.0", "spec_sha256": "a2e714e7daa99a6771c9290b4a008795358032e887356e8f042c203bb08b6c1f", "status": "replay_proxy", "supply": { "components": [ { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "supply_cycle_gate", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Fused component-cycle gate", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": "TIGHT", "raw_value": null, "score": 90, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "chokepoint_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Chokepoint tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.92, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "age_days": null, "as_of": "2023-12-31", "component": "relief_window_tension", "detail": "2023 HBM retrospective proxy reconstruction acquired 2026-07-10; not point-in-time evidence", "evidence_class": "retrospective_proxy", "exclusion_reason": null, "included": true, "knowledge_time": "2026-07-10T00:00:00", "label": "Capacity relief-window tension", "observation_age_days": 0, "raw_label": null, "raw_value": 0.94, "score": 100, "source_coverage": 1, "source_members_expected": [], "source_members_present": [], "source_url": "docs/adr/0081-ai-supercycle-binding-constraint.md", "weight": 0.3333333333333333 } ], "coverage": 1, "label": "Supply tightness", "score": 96.67, "state": "tight" }, "verdict": "DEMAND_LED_TIGHTNESS" } ] }